Skip to main content
American Rare Coin Store

American Rare Coin Store

8.9K items sold
660 followers
Contact

All items

Unsearched Lincoln WHEAT CENTS BAG of 500 Truly Never Searched 1909-1958 Pennies

$59.95

14k Solid Yellow Gold Natural Ruby Insect Bumble Bee Pin Signed 585 Great Cond

$249.00

STEEL WHEAT CENTS BAG of 500 Lincoln WWII Era Circulated Pennies Lot 1943 P D S

$105.95

1838 LARGE CENT F 15 NGC GRADED Coin Coronet Head FINE 15 Nice Looking 1741

$59.00

A. Lecoultre Pocket Watch 15 Jewels Selva Watch Co. Size 10 Rolled Gold Case

$20.547 bids1d 22h 44m

2023-W $25 Palladium Burnished Eagle 1 oz Coin NGC MS70

$2,095.00

1936 LONG ISLAND PCGS MS65 Commemorative Half Dollar Graded Coin 9322 WOW Super

$185.00

1879 S MORGAN PCGS MS64 Graded Silver Dollar MS 64 Coin 7092 San Francisco

$119.50Save up to 6% when you buy more

ROLEX Authentic Vintage 18K Yellow Gold BRACELET for 1803 PRESIDENT Day/Date OEM

$5,850.00

ELGIN Grade 289 Pocket Watch 7 Jewels Vintage Model 2 Size 6 Circa 1905

$17.5011 bids1d 22h 45m

ROLEX Genuine LINKS 18K Yellow Gold PRESIDENT Day-Date 1803 18038 18238 16.2mm

$249.00

Lot Of 7 Vintage Pocket Watches Movements Elgin Richard Crown Illinois

$97.009 bids1d 22h 44m

OMEGA Seamaster Aqua Terra 39mm Quartz 2517.50.00 Black 150M Watch Box & Papers!

$1,590.00

1851 LARGE CENT XF40 NGC GRADED Coin Coronet Head XF 40 Nice Looking 1892

$85.00

1857 FLYING EAGLE NGC Graded F12 Fine 12 Small Cent Coin Nice Looking 2016

$55.00

2018-W $100 Proof 1 oz Platinum Eagle $100 "Life" NGC PF70

$1,495.00

1913 S BUFFALO NICKEL TYPE 1 VG8 Graded NGC VG 8 Nice Original Legible Coin V1

$49.00

Vintage 14ky Solid Gold Hummingbird Brooch Pin Silhouette Flying Figure

$185.00

1953 Washington Quarter PROOF 67 NGC Graded Coin PF67 Brilliant White 5985

$59.00

2023-W $25 Palladium Burnished Eagle 1 oz Coin NGC MS70 Moy Signed Label

$2,295.00

1935 S SAN DIEGO MS64 Commemorative Half Dollar PCGS Graded MS 64 Green Label!

$175.00Save up to 5% when you buy more

1834 Capped Bust HALF DIME VF Details Bent PCGS Silver Very Fine Coin 4281

$95.00

1926-D LINCOLN Cent AU58 PCGS Graded AU 58 Coin 2570

$88.00

1832 Capped Bust HALF DIME Graded PCGS F15 Silver F 15 Fine Sharp Coin 4279

$130.00

1837 Coronet Head LARGE CENT PCGS VF DETAILS Nice Value Coin 1729

$55.00

BUFFALO NICKELS BAG OF 500 FULL DATE Bulk Lot Indian Head Coins 1913-1938

$419.95Save up to 6% when you buy more

ROLEX PRESIDENT 18K Yellow Gold Day-Date 36mm Men's Size Model 1803 Circa 1970

$7,590.00

1878 7 TF Reverse of 1878 MS62 PCGS Graded MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR 7074 Nice Coins

$145.00

1882 MORGAN PCGS MS63 Graded Silver Dollar MS 63 Original Skin Toned Coin 7132

$135.00

1853 LARGE CENT XF40 NGC GRADED Coin Coronet Head XF 40 Nice Looking 1901

$89.00

1882-O MORGAN PCGS MS62 Graded Silver Dollar MS 62 Coin 7136

$79.00

1891 CC MORGAN F15 PCGS Graded Silver Dollar Carson City F 15 Fine Coin 7206

$230.00

1923-S PEACE Silver Dollar MS63 PCGS Graded $1 Coin MS 63 7362

$135.00

1863-S Seated Liberty DIME PCGS Slabbed GOOD Detail Damaged Coin 4638

$199.00

Brand New Never used Cartier Watch Jewelry Inspection Gloves Medium

$49.99

1 oz ENGELHARD PLATINUM 1986 Proof Like Bullion Rounds USA Flag Assay .9995 WOW!

$1,398.00

1857-O Seated Liberty HALF DIME XF Details Cleaned PCGS Silver Coin 4366

$89.00

2006 P & D $10 KENNEDY HALF DOLLAR Original US MINT ROLLS UNCIRCULATED Set of 2

$40.00

2001 P & D $10 KENNEDY HALF DOLLAR Original US MINT ROLLS UNCIRCULATED Set of 2

$49.50Save up to 5% when you buy more

1907 BARBER Half Dollar F15 PCGS Graded 6508 Silver 50 Cents Nice Coin FINE 15

$135.00

1896-S MORGAN PCGS VF25 Graded Silver Dollar San Francisco VF 25 Coin 7244

$195.00

2020-W $25 Palladium Burnished Eagle 1 oz Coin NGC MS70 Two Coin Set

$3,999.00

1931 MS64 Mexico Gold 50 Pesos

$3,895.00

1946 IOWA Commemorative Half Dollar MS64 PCGS OGH Graded White Coin MS 64 9316

$135.00

1882-O/S MORGAN PCGS AU53 STRONG Graded Silver Dollar AU 53 Coin 7138

$139.00

1831 Capped Bust HALF DIME Graded PCGS F15 Silver F 15 Fine Sharp Coin 4278

$130.00

1890 CC MORGAN PCGS VG08 Graded Silver Dollar Carson City VG 8 Coin 7198 Wow!

$195.00

1942 Walking Liberty Half Dollar NGC MS63 Graded Super Beauty UNC 63 Coin 6614

$79.00
Items Per Page
See All

About us

Since 1989, American Rare Coin with over 200 years of numismatic experience on staff is one of the largest coin and precious metals dealers in the Midwest. We sell competitively priced PCGS and NGC Certified coins, all forms of gold and silver bullion, silver dollars, currency, and U.S. Proof/Mint.
Location: United StatesMember since: Oct 22, 2001Seller: americanrarecoinstore
Top Rated SellerAmerican Rare Coin Store is one of eBay's most reputable sellers. Consistently delivers outstanding customer service Learn more

Feedback ratings

Last 12 months

Positive732- positive feedback in last 12 months
Neutral3- neutral feedback in last 12 months
Negative1- negative feedback in last 12 months

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months

Accurate description
5.0
Reasonable shipping cost
4.9
Shipping speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller feedback (5,446)

7***4 (680)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Wonderful eBay transaction! Coin exactly as described and pictured. Good price and super well-packaged. Very fast delivery as well. Thanks!
a***i (13285)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Fast shipping, exactly as described and packaged very very well. I will definitely continue to do business with this seller!! Thanks
o***_ (52)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Very nice coin and the one shown on the photo. Reasonable price for this coin. Packaging was excellent. Recommend seller A++++++++
9***l (291)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past year
Verified purchase
A seller that totally stands behind his site. A huge seller with an awesome rating. Great selection. I purchased then I changed my mind based on my personal tastes. The beautiful pocket watch arrived super fast and my return was treated by this vendor as advertised with no questions asked. They get it as to being a retail shop that customers return items sometimes, it's part of doing business. Totally stress less! Sincerely. Thank you!
y***o (411)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
Really Fast shipping very well packaged better than described 👍👍👍
e***l (1028)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
As described, packaged in a box & shipped quickly, nice old watch👍 thanks
See all feedback